I've had my saxton a little over 2 years now. I got the fabric thunder with the redish wood legs and really love the look. It's the perfect size for my apartment and a great light weight. If you live alone you can move it around solo no problem. It looks beautiful in my space, true to images online. I just personally don't like the cushions. It's not the most uncomfortable thing, but it sinks a little too much and doesn't quite feel like the kind of squishy down should feel like. Also the back cushions aren't quite the same. One is and has always been more squishy than the other, so there's somehow some unevenness in how the down is distributed I guess? Visually I'd give it 5 stars, even worn in I think it looks cute. But the comfort for me is off.
I will say I find it comfortable to sleep on when my weight is distributed over larger surface area (115lbs), but while sitting there's too much give.
A quick note that the sofa came with slight fabric damage to the velvet. It's a small section but I wasn't able to fix it. Customer service did give me a small discount for the damage though.